lit_kitty ([info]lit_kitty) wrote,

Just a little rant...


1. Shippers who ship only one ship. This, I feel, is really the thing that's caused all the wank since Saturday. There are all these people who have one particular ship they like, and they become militant about it. Personally, I ship a whole bunch of ships. That is to say, I enjoy reading a number of ships - if the fic's good. My favourites include (but are not limited to) Ron/Hermione, Harry/Ron, Harry/Ron/Hermione, Ron/Draco, Snape/Hermione, Snape/Harry, Sirius/James, Sirius/Remus, James/Lily, Lily/Remus, Remus/Ginny, Draco/Ginny and Sirius/Snape. Look at all the cross-overs there. I don't particularly care if they become canon or not, because there's such a wealth of good fic out there that I don't NEED it to be fanfic. It's highly unlikely that Harry/Ron/Hermione, probably my OT3, will ever become canon, but I DON'T CARE. And neither should any of you. No ship is ever really sunk, if you're imaginative enough. Young love doesn't always last. JKR doesn't record every detail of every character's life. Let JKR have her canon relationships, and we'll have our fanon ones. There's really no need for all this wank.

2. Fics in which Hermione changes her last name after marriage. I just can't see it happening. She's too progressive, too soapbox-y to do something like that. She likes her independence, and I feel it's OOC of her to change her last name.

3. This irritating convention of Harry/Hermione and Harry/Draco writers to present Ron as the bad guy, or Harry/Ron writers to slag off Hermione. I think it's lazy to put two characters together and instead of working through the issues their close friends might have, and writing it in such a way that all the loved ones are cool with it, to just have other characters go "Well, I can't accept this, I'm going to go off in a tizz." I think it's bad characterisation. Let's look at Ron, first. If Harry and Hermione hooked up, I think he'd be hurt, but he'd get over it. Partly because he feels Harry deserves to have good things, and also because I think he'd be lost without them. If Harry hooked up with Draco, Ron would probably feel DEEPLY betrayed, but if Harry showed him that no, it didn't change things between them and Hermione sat him down and gave him a good talking to, he'd calm down. Likewise, I find it extremely doubtful that Hermione would spaz out over finding out the boys were gay. Seriously. She's uptight, yes, but not about social issues.
The friendship between these three characters is one of the central themes of the books. Yes, there are times when they all want to kill each other, but they always come through it because that's what happens with real friends. They're all very strong people, but it's been said time and time again that they don't cope well when they're fighting, and whenever it comes down to something important, they can forgive each other and move on, because their friendship is more important. To write fic in which one of them storms off forever demonstrates an extremely shallow understanding of the texts.

That is all.
Tags: fandom, shipping

  • Post a new comment

    Error

  • 7 comments

[info]fyrie

July 21 2005, 11:09:55 UTC 6 years ago

On point 2, I could see Hermione making hers a double-barrelled name, so no one would be able to forget that she was not born of wizarding parents, that she still holds dear the Muggle aspect of her heritage :)

[info]juliadactyl

July 21 2005, 11:31:37 UTC 6 years ago

Possibly. However, then she would use the english style, which would be Hermione Granger-(husbandsname), rather than the American style of Hermione Granger (husbandsname). It would be her proper last name, all hyphenated, not become her middle name.

[info]fyrie

July 21 2005, 12:01:04 UTC 6 years ago

Aghreed. Y'know, I didn't even know America did it differently. I always went on the assumption that hyphenation was involved :)

[info]hswift

July 21 2005, 12:52:42 UTC 6 years ago

"I am now...Mrs Harry Potter!"
I really can't see it happening. Is this frequent, or on more of a Ginny/giant squid regularity?

[info]juliadactyl

July 21 2005, 15:12:33 UTC 6 years ago

There's a depressing amount of fic where it happens.

[info]hswift

July 21 2005, 15:59:53 UTC 6 years ago

oh dear. My mind is conjuring up images of 13 year olds wanting to be subservient to the man of their dreams and writing fic with Hermione as proxy.

I'm guessing that's the profile? Haven't been reading fic long enough to tell.

I hope I don't have nightmares about these 13 yr old hordes.

[info]lit_kitty

July 22 2005, 01:51:46 UTC 6 years ago

No, that's not it at all. A lot of the fic is relatively good, and Hermione's still Hermione, it's just that one thing - probably written by people who aren't accustomed to women keeping their last names.
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…